Doc with TS
Question:
MD who grabbed patients convicted of misconduct By Gay Abbate Having Tourette’s syndrome explains only some of Stephen Ross’s strange behaviour with patients and nurses, a discipline committee of the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons has concluded. The committee convicted the Toronto-area family physician of professional misconduct. But it dismissed as unproven charges that he sexually assaulted hospital employees and patients. Dr. Ross, 51, used Tourette’s, a syndrome characterized by facial and body tics that can lead to jerking movements and to compulsive behaviour, to explain grabbing, pinching, tickling and verbally abusing nurses and patients.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -"Jo Cohen" <joco…@comcast.net> wrote in message > MD who grabbed patients convicted of misconduct > By Gay Abbate > Having Tourette’s syndrome explains only some of Stephen Ross’s > strange behaviour with patients and nurses, a discipline committee > of > the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons has concluded. > The committee convicted the Toronto-area family physician of > professional misconduct. But it dismissed as unproven charges that > he > sexually assaulted hospital employees and patients. > Dr. Ross, 51, used Tourette’s, a syndrome characterized by facial > and > body tics that can lead to jerking movements and to compulsive > behaviour, to explain grabbing, pinching, tickling and verbally > abusing nurses and patients.
I just searched for this in The Toronto Star. www.thestar.com Type Tourette in the "7 day search". I’m puzzled about something Dr. Sandor is quoted as saying there. i.e. "One in five Tourette’s patients has difficulty reading social signals."
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Subject: Re: Doc with TS >From: "Lara" kbu…@tpg.com.au >Date: 10/28/04 4:13 PM Pacific Daylight Time >Message-id: <41817…@dnews.tpgi.com.au> >"Jo Cohen" <joco…@comcast.net> wrote in message >> MD who grabbed patients convicted of misconduct >> By Gay Abbate >> Having Tourette’s syndrome explains only some of Stephen Ross’s >> strange behaviour with patients and nurses, a discipline committee >> of >> the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons has concluded. >> The committee convicted the Toronto-area family physician of >> professional misconduct. But it dismissed as unproven charges that >> he >> sexually assaulted hospital employees and patients. >> Dr. Ross, 51, used Tourette’s, a syndrome characterized by facial >> and >> body tics that can lead to jerking movements and to compulsive >> behaviour, to explain grabbing, pinching, tickling and verbally >> abusing nurses and patients. >I just searched for this in The Toronto Star. www.thestar.com >Type Tourette in the "7 day search". >I’m puzzled about something Dr. Sandor is quoted as saying there. >i.e. "One in five Tourette’s patients has difficulty reading social >signals."
What’s puzzling about that? TS’ers have an impulse disorder. Their having an impulse disorder necissatates they focus an inordinate amount of attention internally to guard against or suppress their impulses or acting on impulse. their having to pay an inordinate amount of conscious attention to what’s going on internally, diverting attention from what’s all going down in the externeal world around them. Think about what happens when you drive a car. Your mind attends to the conditions on the road, while your body movements to adjust steering wheel, change gears, speed up or slow down are automatic, second nature –done without conscious thought. But, if you have a tic that impels you to jerk the steering wheel, or step on the gas, or the brake, or flick the signal lights on and off…your life depends upon your giving an inordinate amount of attention to guarding against, suppressing or not acting on such impulse. Therefoe, your attention is INTERNALLY focused, rather than externatlly focused…so you constantly failing to notice changing conditions on the road or the signals of the cars around you. Living with tourettes is like having to navigate highly trafficed road ways, while most of your attention is focused on what’s going on inside the car, rather than outside of it. smash, boom, bam—-you are accident prone socially.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -"Tiffanyattrop" <tiffanyatt…@aol.com> wrote in message > >Subject: Re: Doc with TS >>From: "Lara" kbu…@tpg.com.au >>Date: 10/28/04 4:13 PM Pacific Daylight Time >>Message-id: <41817…@dnews.tpgi.com.au> >>"Jo Cohen" <joco…@comcast.net> wrote in message >>> MD who grabbed patients convicted of misconduct >>> By Gay Abbate >>> Having Tourette’s syndrome explains only some of Stephen Ross’s >>> strange behaviour with patients and nurses, a discipline committee >>> of >>> the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons has concluded. >>> The committee convicted the Toronto-area family physician of >>> professional misconduct. But it dismissed as unproven charges that >>> he >>> sexually assaulted hospital employees and patients. >>> Dr. Ross, 51, used Tourette’s, a syndrome characterized by facial >>> and >>> body tics that can lead to jerking movements and to compulsive >>> behaviour, to explain grabbing, pinching, tickling and verbally >>> abusing nurses and patients. >>I just searched for this in The Toronto Star. www.thestar.com >>Type Tourette in the "7 day search". >>I’m puzzled about something Dr. Sandor is quoted as saying there. >>i.e. "One in five Tourette’s patients has difficulty reading social >>signals." > What’s puzzling about that? > TS’ers have an impulse disorder. > Their having an impulse disorder necissatates they focus an > inordinate amount > of attention internally to guard against or suppress their impulses > or acting > on impulse. > their having to pay an inordinate amount of conscious attention to > what’s > going on internally, diverting attention from what’s all going down > in the > externeal world around them. > Think about what happens when you drive a car. > Your mind attends to the conditions on the road, while your body > movements to > adjust steering wheel, change gears, speed up or slow down are > automatic, > second nature –done without conscious thought. > But, if you have a tic that impels you to jerk the steering wheel, > or step on > the gas, or the brake, or flick the signal lights on and > off…your life > depends upon your giving an inordinate amount of attention to > guarding against, > suppressing or not acting on such impulse. > Therefoe, your attention is INTERNALLY focused, rather than > externatlly > focused…so you constantly failing to notice changing conditions on > the road > or the signals of the cars around you. > Living with tourettes is like having to navigate highly trafficed > road ways, > while most of your attention is focused on what’s going on inside > the car, > rather than outside of it. > smash, boom, bam—-you are accident prone socially.
What’s that got to do with the ability to read social signals? Those things you have written about weren’t what I was thinking a social signal would be. I’m asking a serious question because I don’t understand what the good doctor meant. Lara
Response:
"Lara" <kbu…@tpg.com.au> wrote in message
news:4182b4cc@dnews.tpgi.com.au… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> "Tiffanyattrop" <tiffanyatt…@aol.com> wrote in message > > >Subject: Re: Doc with TS > >>From: "Lara" kbu…@tpg.com.au > >>Date: 10/28/04 4:13 PM Pacific Daylight Time > >>Message-id: <41817…@dnews.tpgi.com.au> > >>"Jo Cohen" <joco…@comcast.net> wrote in message > >>> MD who grabbed patients convicted of misconduct > >>> By Gay Abbate > >>> Having Tourette’s syndrome explains only some of Stephen Ross’s > >>> strange behaviour with patients and nurses, a discipline committee > >>> of > >>> the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons has concluded. > >>> The committee convicted the Toronto-area family physician of > >>> professional misconduct. But it dismissed as unproven charges that > >>> he > >>> sexually assaulted hospital employees and patients. > >>> Dr. Ross, 51, used Tourette’s, a syndrome characterized by facial > >>> and > >>> body tics that can lead to jerking movements and to compulsive > >>> behaviour, to explain grabbing, pinching, tickling and verbally > >>> abusing nurses and patients. > >>I just searched for this in The Toronto Star. www.thestar.com > >>Type Tourette in the "7 day search". > >>I’m puzzled about something Dr. Sandor is quoted as saying there. > >>i.e. "One in five Tourette’s patients has difficulty reading social > >>signals." > > What’s puzzling about that? > > TS’ers have an impulse disorder. > > Their having an impulse disorder necissatates they focus an > > inordinate amount > > of attention internally to guard against or suppress their impulses > > or acting > > on impulse. > > their having to pay an inordinate amount of conscious attention to > > what’s > > going on internally, diverting attention from what’s all going down > > in the > > externeal world around them. > > Think about what happens when you drive a car. > > Your mind attends to the conditions on the road, while your body > > movements to > > adjust steering wheel, change gears, speed up or slow down are > > automatic, > > second nature –done without conscious thought. > > But, if you have a tic that impels you to jerk the steering wheel, > > or step on > > the gas, or the brake, or flick the signal lights on and > > off…your life > > depends upon your giving an inordinate amount of attention to > > guarding against, > > suppressing or not acting on such impulse. > > Therefoe, your attention is INTERNALLY focused, rather than > > externatlly > > focused…so you constantly failing to notice changing conditions on > > the road > > or the signals of the cars around you. > > Living with tourettes is like having to navigate highly trafficed > > road ways, > > while most of your attention is focused on what’s going on inside > > the car, > > rather than outside of it. > > smash, boom, bam—-you are accident prone socially. > What’s that got to do with the ability to read social signals? > Those things you have written about weren’t what I was thinking a > social signal would be. > I’m asking a serious question because I don’t understand what the good > doctor meant.
I am giving you a serious answer. The two primary reasons TS children capacity to read social cues isn’t as well developed as other children are as follows: The TS child primary caretakers have Tourettes and their ticcing makes their body language and social signals confusing to the ts child so they stop trying to read what makes no sense. The TS child’s attention in social situations is ALWAYS divided between what’s going on internally, suppressing tics, and resisting impulses, and the external world…with an inordinate amount of focus on consciously inhibiting impulses owing to their not having the inhibition system built into most other children’s brain. Children not having to divide their attention can attend to what’s going on around them in social situations and learn social signals easily….which TS children divided attention makes them oblivious to.
Response:
Hey, you guys, don’t get too excited: the reporting in this case, with which I’m familiar is INADEQUATE (as usual). There’s no evidence I know of that 1 in 5 persons with TS has difficulty reading social signals. The question here (IMHO) wasn’t the TS (only): it was whether a doctor who was doing all these weird things for years had a responsibility to do something about it, or to explain himself — tics or not, even if he didn’t knopw his official diagnoses. Roger "TSN" <t…@optonline.net> wrote in message
news:4183EFED.29D9191E@optonline.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Lara wrote: > > >>"Jo Cohen" <joco…@comcast.net> wrote in message > > >>> MD who grabbed patients convicted of misconduct > > >>> By Gay Abbate > > >>> Having Tourette’s syndrome explains only some of Stephen Ross’s > > >>> strange behaviour with patients and nurses, a discipline committee > > >>> of > > >>> the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons has concluded. > > >>> The committee convicted the Toronto-area family physician of > > >>> professional misconduct. But it dismissed as unproven charges that > > >>> he sexually assaulted hospital employees and patients. > > >>> Dr. Ross, 51, used Tourette’s, a syndrome characterized by facial > > >>> and > > >>> body tics that can lead to jerking movements and to compulsive > > >>> behaviour, to explain grabbing, pinching, tickling and verbally > > >>> abusing nurses and patients. > Jo, it would be great if you would provide the URL when you quote an > article. > Besides being good practice, it helps us track down the source of the > article, read the entire article, and we wouldn’t want you to be charged > with copyright violation for quoting an article without citing the source. > In trying to follow up on Lara’s question, I found what seems to be the > source of your article:
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/ArticleNews/TPStory/LAC/200410… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> It was appropriately titled (emphasis mine): > MD who grabbed patients CONVICTED OF MISCONDUCT > And, I found this article > http://www.simcoe.com/sc/alliston/story/2308986p-2675750c.html > which was also titled, > College says Ross GUILTY OF MISCONDUCT. > "A doctor who recently pleaded guilty to numerous criminal charges, > including sexual assault, has been found guilty of professional misconduct > by the body that governs physicians in Ontario. However, the > disciplinary committee for the College of Physicians and Surgeons of > Ontario found Dr. Stephen Ross not guilty of the more serious charges it > was considering, the alleged sexual abuse of staff and patients. > His lawyer told the committee Ross couldn’t help himself because he > suffers from Tourette’s Syndrome (TS). " > Fortunately, the man had already pleaded guilty in the criminal case for > sexual assault, before the panel of 5 made it harder for persons with tics > to become physicians. > The day that Tourette’s is accepted as a legal excuse for a physician’s > criminal behavior is the day that it will be harder for persons with tics > to become physicians. > And I can name several people I know with TS, ADHD and OCD who would make > great and competent physicians, and who do know right from wrong. > When "he couldn’t help himself because of TS" becomes a legal excuse for > criminal conduct, we’re all in trouble. > Some five member committee decided to ignore the fact that he had already > pleaded guilty to criminal charges, and accept the reasoning of a > psychiatrist who conferred a TS diagnosis as the explanation for his > behavior. > A dangerous precedent: physician gets into criminal trouble, and another > physician explains it with recently-diagnosed TS. > Oops, the tics made me do it. > The tics made me hit the accelerator pedal and run over and kill the > fellow, too (Anne Heche case – who remembers the show?) > > >>I just searched for this in The Toronto Star. www.thestar.com > > >>Type Tourette in the "7 day search". > > >>I’m puzzled about something Dr. Sandor is quoted as saying there. > > >>i.e. "One in five Tourette’s patients has difficulty reading social > > >>signals." > Besides the fact that either the reporter, or the psychiatrist, failed to > provide a more thorough discussion of comorbid conditions when present > along with TS, it is interesting to note the Toronto Star’s headline, in > contrast to the other two. > While other newspaper headlines are emphasizing that Ross was GUILTY > (appropriate, considering he had already pleaded guilty), the Toronto Star > chose to angle their story with a headline of: > Doctor with Tourette’s CLEARED of sexual abuse
http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=thestar/Layou… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> "A Toronto-area doctor who poked and touched patients and rubbed against > nurses has been cleared of sexual abuse by a disciplinary board, > partially because he has Tourette’s syndrome. > Ross is the first doctor to cite this disease as part of his defence in a > disciplinary hearing before the college. > The condition affecting the married father of four went undiagnosed until > he was examined in 2003 by Toronto psychiatrist Dr. Paul Sandor, who also > found that Ross suffers from attention deficit syndrome and > obsessive-compulsive disorder. > One in five Tourette’s patients has difficulty reading social signals, and > Ross tended to minimize the effect of his actions, Sandor said." > Given that the Toronto Star has come under increasing scrutiny because of > its bias, the choice of their headline and story angle is not surprising. > > I’m asking a serious question because I don’t understand what the good > > doctor meant. > Who does? > — > Tourette Syndrome – Now What? > http://tourettenowwhat.tripod.com
Response:
"Roger D. Freeman, M.D." wrote: > Hey, you guys, don’t get too excited: the reporting in this case, with which > I’m familiar is INADEQUATE (as usual).
That’s no surprise … "as usual" for sure !! Each newspaper seemed to put a whole different spin on the story ! > There’s no evidence I know of that 1 in 5 persons with TS has difficulty > reading social signals.
whew — thought not
) I hope the reporters, rather than the physicians involved, were responsible for the misquoting. > The question here (IMHO) wasn’t the TS (only): it was whether a doctor who > was doing all these weird things for years had a responsibility to do > something about it, or to explain himself — tics or not, even if he didn’t > knopw his official diagnoses.
No kidding … that sums it up nicely. It seems to me that, tics or not, a Dr. does have a responsibility to know right from wrong in terms of how he interacts with patients and co-workers. As it seems (from all I’ve read) that Mort Doran, with TS, OCD and ADHD, was able to do … — Tourette Syndrome – Now What? http://tourettenowwhat.tripod.com
Response:
[ Not to be confused with other recent ast Linda nyms: "Adinl" <Ad...@nospam.com> adinlli...@aol.com (Adinllinda) getnstron...@hotmail.com (Linda) Linda <li...@om.nspmcom> "Linda" <Li...@noemail.com> "Linda" <Li...@nospam.com> LInda <Li...@nospam.com> Linda <Li...@nospam.comnojunk> "Linda" <li...@nozpam.com> Li...@nspam.comnojunk "Linda" <li...@y.comnojunk> Linda <Li...@zom.nspmcom> "Linda" <nos...@nospam.com> lindaglasve...@aol.comnojunk (Linda) tiffanyatt...@aol.com (Tiffanyattrop) ] – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -"Adinl" <Ad…@nospam.com> wrote: > "Lara" <kbu…@tpg.com.au> wrote in message > news:4182b4cc@dnews.tpgi.com.au… > > What’s that got to do with the ability to read social signals? > > Those things you have written about weren’t what I was thinking a > > social signal would be. > > I’m asking a serious question because I don’t understand what the good > > doctor meant. > I am giving you a serious answer. > The two primary reasons TS children capacity to read social cues isn’t as > well developed as other children are as follows: > The TS child primary caretakers have Tourettes and their ticcing makes their > body language and social signals confusing to the ts child so they stop > trying to read what makes no sense.
I can’t figure what data or reasoning this statement is based upon. Why do you assume that all or most primary caretakers of children with TS also have TS? Or that, if they did, their tics would confuse the child’s ability to read social cues? (For example, do shoulder shrugging or neck stretching or throat clearing cause problems for children in interpreting social cues?) > The TS child’s attention in social situations is ALWAYS divided between > what’s going on internally, suppressing tics, and resisting impulses, and > the external world…with an inordinate amount of focus on consciously > inhibiting impulses owing to their not having the inhibition system built > into most other children’s brain.
You assume that all children with TS are always trying to suppress tics ? You further assume that this prevents them from reading social cues? It doesn’t fit here, at all. In fact, the opposite argument could be made: that children with tics are MORE tuned in to social cues, because they are aware of or concerned about being teased or being different. > Children not having to divide their attention can attend to what’s going on > around them in social situations and learn social signals easily….which > TS children divided attention makes them oblivious to.
Two children with tics here, no problems with understanding or interpreting social cues, in fact, both very well versed in those areas.
Response:
‘Twas Sat, 30 Oct 2004 15:47:57 -0400 when all alt.support.tourette stood in awe as TSN <t…@optonline.net> uttered: >Jo, it would be great if you would provide the URL when you quote an >article.
ditto >In trying to follow up on Lara’s question, I found what seems to be the >source of your article: >http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/ArticleNews/TPStory/LAC/200410… >It was appropriately titled (emphasis mine): >MD who grabbed patients CONVICTED OF MISCONDUCT
News headlines are an interesting thing. The most important thing to remember, the writer of the article provides a title, but the editors always change it. Sometimes a single title goes out on the wire and nearly everyone uses it, but more often the story runs with dozens of titles, reflecting the editor’s spin. — RB |